Skip to main content

Trick or Treat?

I plan to post pictures of my special day later today but in the meantime... Is there anyone brave enough to answer IF you trick or treat with your children and if you do NOT, do you plan alternative activities? If you do, what kind?

I know that this is very controversial among Christians and since this is "Crosswalk" and I would like to bring up some cultural issues in our walk with Christ and how other Christian families face them.

Remember you can post anonymously but just please be kind :-)

Comments

Anonymous said…
I'll be brave enough to even post my name! We do trick or treat - usually around my mom & dad's neighborhood where there are lots of families and everyone is extremely welcoming and safety conscious. Our church usually has a "harvest party" on a day other than Halloween and they have been very Christ centered - we loved the one that "traveled" through the life of Moses! This year they have decided to hold the party on Halloween since it is a Wednesday and insist on only Biblical costumes - I have a feeling that there won't be a huge crowd. I appreciate that we can get caught up in things that are seemingly celebrating something other than Christ - I also see the side that if dealt with correctly - to most kids it is a night to dress up and get candy. We actually enjoy the fellowship with family and getting out into the community to interact with other people. Of course, I am very outreach driven and think we need to reach out to the community instead of isolating ourselves inside our church walls. I think we can stand firm in our beliefs and still love people like Jesus. But that is just what I am thinking! I am not offended if others feel differently. This year we asked our church to forgo their usual children's Easter event and instead hold a huge community Block Party ON Palm Sunday that included LOTS of stuff for kids and adults. I believe that we truly lived out the Easter story to our community and had in addition to our own church people - 400 people that had never stepped foot onto our church grounds before. God was honored - even if in a different way than we would normally think. I think in everything we check out hearts and motives and convey that to our children.
w2wkb said…
We trick or treat as well. Our church is having a "Trunk or Treat" as well for the community. Candy and Watchtower mags will be given out of the trunks of members cars.
w2wkb said…
Just kidding about the literature. :-) Maybe Chick Tracts instead. :-)
Anonymous said…
William - I see you haven't changed a bit!
Twila G. said…
We do not trick or treat. When I was in college I remember a Christian radio broadcast documenting the things that go on by Satanists and others involved with the Occult on Halloween. I was so sickened by it that I could never think of Halloween in an innocent way again, and never ever wanted to have anything to do with celebrating it in any way. Fortunately, my husband agrees with me. However, even though
we're not Catholic, we opt to celebrate All Saints Day on November 1. My kids get lots of candy and we have a special "Family Night" together.
Anonymous said…
We do go trick or treating. I asked the kids in Sunday School if everyone knew what they would be & they blew my head off with reasons why they don't go. I can see the negativity, but there's so much junk in this world that if we let that interfere in our lives we would never leave our homes. So, we go & have fun, we don't dress in anything evil, last year I ended up with a princess & a hot dog. One of us stays here for a while so our house does give treats as well as the kids receiving from other neighbors. To each his own, but we do & I believe I'm still going to Heaven :)
~Laura
Rachel said…
When I was growing up I wasn't allowed to dress up but we were able to go to Grandma's house and hand out popcorn balls that we had helped to make. It was a huge family event because all of the cousin's would come over. I was never told that Halloween was a bad thing but just something we didn't do. What we currently do with Caleb is allow him to dress up in a fun costume (not scary) and participate in the local trunk or treat that is put on by a large church in our area. Last year he also visited the nursing home where we know a couple of people and participated in their hall trick or treat. It brought great enjoyment to the resident's of the nursing home and he had a great time. I think we have to find balance in our Christian lives in how we celebrate special days on the calendar.
Unknown said…
I think one year the kids had to trick or treat during the day and my parents allowed us to go. I dressed up like a cat. Go figure- you know what a cat lover that I am - NOT! I think that was the only year we ever went. My mom would usually let us pick out a bag or two of candy that we liked which is a fun memory for me. Blake still isn't old enough to know the difference and I'm not sure how we will handle it when he is. He did wear a punkin costume last year to just show him off at work though. I like the harvest party idea. Halloween just spooks me out. I think it's because there are so many gross and evil looking costumes.
Unknown said…
I have sat down to write a response to this at least 4 times and got interrupted. So I'll try again.

Thanks to each of you for responding. I didn't even realize that there were some Christians who didn't trick or treat until we moved to Kentucky and we realized our closest neighbors weren't particpating. They never spoke of it but we thought so highly of them and their walk with Christ that is gave us pause to think twice.

I'll be honest I wish we had thought this one through when Zachary was a baby (or before). I don't think that we would have done it. Now if it was something that we were certain was going to interfere with boys walk with Christ--we would STOP now. But it is completely innocent to them. They have no desire to dress in cross gender clothing(YIKES!) or spooky things. Over the years I think we have had a scarecrow, 2 clowns, a pumpkin, an elephant, a monkey, a pirate, a cowboy, a baseball player, etc. We have gone to the zoo where booths were set up and in our neighborhood. It has been a family activity that we enjoyed.

The church here has a community wide harvest party and we plan on taking the boys there. I think that like Sandi mentioned it is, in part, to bring people who would not otherwise come to church to a gathering that is used to promote the love of God.

William or anyonelse, what are chick tracks? :-) I am pretty certain there won't be watchtower mags there unless some come to try to convert Southern Baptists.:-)

Twila, I am so naive but what is All Saints Day and why is it celebrated?

I really appreciate all of your comments. As iron sharpens iron, so one wo/man sharpens another!
Twila G. said…
All Saints Day is a day, predominantly celebrated by Catholics and Anglicans I think, that remembers saints and martyrs throughout history. For us it is becoming a day to remember those Christians who have sacrificed so much for Christ and to thank God for our religious freedom. It seems to me to be something that is a positive thing to celebrate. My husband asks those who question him about why we don't celebrate Halloween, what they are celebrating on that day. He can't figure out what we're celebrating on Halloween. We celebrate love on Valentines, Christ's resurrection on Easter, our nation's independence on the 4th of July, and of course Christ's birth on Christmas. But what are we celebrating on Halloween? Nobody seems to know exactly what we're celebrating. The answer becomes increasely difficult when we see our neighbors hanging skeletons from ropes in their trees. What do you tell your kids when they see this kind of thing?! And isn't it more difficult to answer if they are supposed to join in the "celebration". In fact a person hung himself around Halloween last year. He was left hanging for quite some time even during the day because people initially thought it was Halloween decorations!!? With these kind of decorations you have to wonder about the party. We realize that many of our Christian friends find it a day to have fun dressing up the kids and we respect their decision; however, to us it seems that if you pull back the veil of the "celebration" that what you find underneath may really need a mask! (Okay I'll confess my husband typed those last several sentences) :) Anyways, I feel like the lone ranger here, but its nice to have a forum to discuss these types of topics.
Unknown said…
Twila,
I want this to be a forum to discuss Christian issues and I am thankful that you are wiling to post even if you feel outnumbered!

You are not alone. I know that here are several believers who do not celebrate (and even read this blog) but do not comment--that's why I left it open to anonomity.

Thank Keith, for his comments. It is food for thought and I'm anxious for David to read "your" comments. :-)

I think that the All Saints Day is a neat way to teach children about an important part of Christian history.

Everytime David tells the boys the scenario of Bishops Nicholas Ridley and Hugh Latimer being burned at the stake...when He gets to the part where Ridley was encouraging Latimer, "Be of good comfort, Mr. Ridley and play the man! We shall this day light such a candle by God's grace, in England, as I trust never shall be put out"...I weep.

Where do you go for celebrations of this sort?
Twila G. said…
Thats a good question. Other than going to Mass, I don't know of any other place where they celebrate All Saints Day. So we just do our own celebration. Alot of my childrens friends and even some of their cousins trick or treat and I don't like to make my kids feel "deprived". They really look forward to our special celebration
together. I make sure they get plenty of treats and even a gift or two.
Unknown said…
Thanks again for the food for thought. David and I have enjoyed discussing this today.

I would really like to post questions now and then about how Christians keep the faith in today's culture. David and I have thought about several topics but I'd like to hear from you too. If any of you have an idea, post it or email me, please.
Mary Ellen said…
Since I was gone all weekend I'm late on this one but will post anyway! As kids we always were allowed to dress up (nothing evil or scary) and went trick or treating mainly to peoples homes that we knew. When we got older we were aware that there were people who used it as a night to party and make it about darkness and evil but had no desire to participate. Even when I was too old to go I would dress up with a friend and we would take little kids we babysat. Later our school
had a lock in at the dining hall and you could dress as a Biblical or historical character - it was a blast. Once I was in college we had more than one year where we had a party at my parents where everyone came dressed up and we ate and played hilarious games - a lot of laughs and funny pictures. I went every year, dressed up, with the boys I was a nanny for in NY - even to a non Christian family it was just a time to dress up and get candy. We allow our children to dress up in fun outfits - nothing scary or evil - and we go in my sisters family friendly neighbor hood, we have also gone to local church events. For us we think just like "the world" has taken religious holidays (Christian and Easter) and made it all about Santa Clause and the Easter bunny we can take what some use as an evil holiday and make it the opposite - all about clean fun, family and playing dress up! For us it has nothing to do with religion or celebrating something - it is just one night to do something fun and unusual you don't do any other night of the year. Before any shennagins start taking place our kids are all fast asleep! "-) I think it is great that so many churches are providing safe alternatives for those that don't live in family friendly neighborhoods. Our backyard has hosted our churches Fall party for kids 12 and under, they can dress up appropriately, many times and we've always had a good turnout.
Anonymous said…
Good topic, Amy!
I guess not everyone likes it, but our church has had 'Hallelujah' night on Halloween for many years. Everyone dresses up like a bible character, ton's of kids come, there are prizes for costumes etc etc. I totally enjoy it. Of course we do occaisionally get some interesting costuems. Like one year a gal in an apple costume had a label that read 'forbidden fruit'. It was quite the costume. Then there was the young lady that came as Lazarus, and her swaddling bands started coming apart before the evening was over... Fortunately there were plenty of long coats available, as it can be VERY cold here by that time of year.
Uncle Tim

Popular posts from this blog

Homeschooling Curriculum Help?

Shannon is hosting a backwards edition of what-works-for-me Wednesday , where you can ask for advice/ or suggestions instead of giving them. Yeah! I need some advice. David and I are really praying and considering homeschooling our boys, K4 and grades 2 and 6 —beginning this fall. Can anybody recommend a curriculum, either as a whole or as a subject, that you are crazy about that doesn’t make you crazy? Secondly, if you could give one tip for “survival” what would that be?

February 27 Update

I just called to see if Amy wanted to blog anything today, but at the moment she is talking on the phone to her wonderful friend, Deb Rose. Deb and her husband, Brian, used to live in Louisville several years ago. They were our very best friends. If I were talking to the Roses this evening, I would tell them that Amy is desperately scared. The docs have given her a very stiff dose of antibiotics, but as of this moment, her body temp is climbing once again. Her primary doctor told her he fears that this infection may be fungal in nature. I don’t completely understand all of the implications, except that we are shooting at this infection with our biggest guns, but it just keeps on coming. In her introspective manner, she shared with me today that if she had known she would lose her sight, she would have invested it more wisely in the things she read and watched: “What if I go completely blind and can’t read the Bible? I have to get more serious about memorizing.” This morning a do

March 8

Amy does not feel well enough to blog today, so the sub is blogging on her behalf. Yesterday Amy thought she saw some new spots in her left eye and felt that she was experiencing some of the same sensations that she had during her stroke, so she went to the doctor. He said that he sees no new lesions, but that doesn’t mean that she couldn’t have another stroke. He recommended that she begin steroids to reduce any retinal inflammation. Amy continues to need your prayers. Blessings, David